California Backs Down on Dangerous Age-Gating Expansion – But the Fight Isn't Over

What Happened with California's Age-Gating Law?

California recently pulled A.B. 1856, a proposed expansion of its age-gating law that would have required browsers and websites to verify users' ages. The original law, A.B. 1043, remains in effect, mandating that operating systems and app stores collect user ages. This retreat is a win for privacy advocates, but the underlying law still raises serious concerns.

Why Age Verification Is a Privacy Nightmare

Imagine having to show your ID every time you want to read a news article or watch a cat video. That's essentially what age-gating laws do online. They force platforms to collect sensitive personal data, creating honeypots for hackers and chilling free expression. As the EFF notes, these laws often backfire, harming the very kids they aim to protect.

The Original Law: A.B. 1043

A.B. 1043 requires operating systems and app stores to estimate or verify users' ages. While less intrusive than the expansion, it still pressures companies to implement age checks, which can lead to data collection and surveillance. Critics argue it's a slippery slope toward mandatory ID checks for all online activity.

What's Next?

Advocates are pushing for alternatives that protect kids without sacrificing privacy, like device-level parental controls. For now, the withdrawal of A.B. 1856 is a relief, but the fight for digital rights continues. Stay informed and support organizations like the EFF that defend your online freedoms.

FAQ